I am a long time supporter of women’s rights in general, and a woman’s right to make her own medical decisions in specific. Even back in the mid 1960s, when I first became involved, women could get an abortion in situations where it was medically necessary. But some Republicans have introduced a bill that would allow women to die in the waiting rooms of hospitals run by or under the influence of the Republican religious right. This is RepubliCare in action.
TPM’s Evan McMorris-Santoro provides the background on the Federal Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTLA) and how a radical new bill introduced by Rep. Joe Pitts (R-PA) would carve out an abortion exemption to it that would allow women seeking medical care to be refused treatement.
A bit of backstory: currently, all hospitals in America that receive Medicare or Medicaid funding are bound by a 1986 law known as EMTALA to provide emergency care to all comers, regardless of their ability to pay or other factors. Hospitals do not have to provide free care to everyone that arrives at their doorstep under EMTALA — but they do have to stabilize them and provide them with emergency care without factoring in their ability to pay for it or not. If a hospital can’t provide the care a patient needs, it is required to transfer that patient to a hospital that can, and the receiving hospital is required to accept that patient.
In the case of an anti-abortion hospital with a patient requiring an emergency abortion, ETMALA would require that hospital to perform it or transfer the patient to someone who can. (The nature of how that procedure works exactly is up in the air, with the ACLU calling on the federal government to state clearly that unwillingness to perform an abortion doesn’t qualify as inability under EMTALA. That argument is ongoing, and the government has yet to weigh in.)
Pitts’ new bill would free hospitals from any abortion requirement under EMTALA, meaning that medical providers who aren’t willing to terminate pregnancies wouldn’t have to — nor would they have to facilitate a transfer.
The hospital could literally do nothing at all, pro-choice critics of Pitts’ bill say.
"This is really out there," Donna Crane, policy director at NARAL Pro-Choice America told TPM. "I haven’t seen this before."
Crane said she’s been a pro-choice advocate "for a long time," yet she’s never seen anti-abortion bill as brazenly attacking the health of the mother exemption as Pitts’ bill has. NARAL has fired up its lobbying machinery and intends to make the emergency abortion language a key part of its fight against the Pitts bill when it goes before subcommittee in the House next week. [emphasis mine]
It seems step one should be demanding that the government clear up any confusion about "ability" vs. "willingness" of hospitals to perform medically necessary abortions in emergency situations… [emphasis original]
Inserted from <Daily Kos>
What makes this particularly insane is that we’re not even talking about choice here. These are life-threatening emergencies. Their willingness to let women die betrays the Republican “pro life” lie. They are pro death.
12 Responses to “The Republican Death Bill for Women”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
much more is involved here ; They are anti women–They are only beginning the assault on women , This is an opening shot in what well may become outright war on women’s reproductive rights and choices–
Phyllis, I fully agree. I found this instance even more heinous, because it wasn’t even about choice.
It would serve them right to have this Teapublican idiocy come back and bite them in the ASS … BIG TIME!
So would I, Nameless. Sadly, this did not get a peep so far on the Sunday shows.
I am also a supporter of a woman’s rights Tom, and daily I am astonished by how few they have in a country like the United States, keeping the dynamic of “lip service” in mind of course. They may have the rights on paper but in the real world it is more mythical. The fact that these crazy Republicans are trying to deprive women of even more rights just boggles the mind.
Mike, I’m so much so that five salesmen quit my employ in 1973, because I promoted a woman over them. When she asked why I told her she was the best man for the job. I thought she was going to hit me, but she realized that I am a male chauvinist pig only in jest.
GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!
Well said, Mark.
What do you expect from the Party Of Death. Just look to Arizona and Jan Brewers Death Panels.
This is what I expect. I’ve done several pieces on Jan Brewer, the RepubliCare Death Angel.
I’m just shaking my head in disgust.
So am I Jer. This one is even worse than HB 3.