Yesterday evening at 5:51 PM PDT, I watched the gates at the border of Kuwait closing behind the last vehicle of the last combat brigade to leave Iraq. I could not help but reflect on the long struggle to bring this war to an end. For me it began in 2001. On the morning of September 11, I was at work and, like most Americans, feeling stunned. My job that day was to contact CTOs and VP ITs in Fortune 500 companies in Manhattan to arrange site visits by a research team from a major software manufacturer. A made two calls, actually talked to someone in the WTC. The man asked me to call his wife and tell her that he loved her. I did. I felt totally freaked out! After that I refused to make more calls and was almost fired, but our company’s President showed up, sided with me, and suspended operations for the rest of the day. We gathered in the lunch room and a friend asked me what it all meant. I correctly identified Al Qaeda as the most likely culprit, and added that I felt certain that Bush would use the attack as an excuse to invade Iraq and curtail the rights of US citizens. Little did I know jusyt how prophetic I was. Nine long years later, these questions remain.
Why?
Bush took us to war for two, perhaps three reasons. Many neocons in the AEI and PNAC wanted GHW Bush to overthrow Saddam and had wanted to finish the job ever since, but this is the least of the factors. The dominant radical Wahhabi sect in Saudi Arabia takes strong exception to the presence of foreign troops so close to Islam’s two most sacred shrines. Thus, it would have been beneficial to Saudi relations to establish permanent military bases elsewhere in the Gulf. Iraq was an ideal location. Bush wanted to control the world’s fourth largest oil reserves for his cronies in US oil companies. UK participation cut BP in on the deal. Operation Iraqi Freedom was always a Republican lie, along with WMD and connections to 9/11. Iraq was always Bush’s war for oil and conquest.
Is it over?
In a word, No. 6.000 more combat troops will fly home within a week, and US forces remaining will officially be on combat status until August 31. Even after that, 50,000 troops will remain in so-called noncombatant roles. Those roles include embedding with Iraqi units as advisors. Having embedded troops in combat units is combat. Those roles will also include special forces operations against terrorists. Operations against terrorists is combat. So this withdrawal is more a media event than anything else. The two good things here are that Obama is completing the withdrawal on time and the the last 50,000 troops must be out by the end of 2011.
Who won?
The Iraqi people did not win. They may have gotten rid of a horrific dictator, but who can say if what comes will be any better? Far too many Iraqis have been killed. Estimates range from 160,000 to 1,300,000 as of October, 2008. Since the highest comes from Lancet, I consider it the most credible. Millions have been dislocated. The nation’s infrastructure is destroyed. Despite billions spent by taxpayers to restore it, Bush’s Republican minions squandered the money on corrupt Iraqi officials and criminal US corporations. Women had more rights under Saddam than they do now. At this point, Iraq doesn’t even have a government.
The US did not win. 4,415 of our fine troops have been killed and thousands more maimed. We have squandered about $800 billion on direct war costs, and that does not even include the cost of reequipping our units or providing well-deserved care for vets whose minds and bodies have been shattered in this war. Through no fault of our fine troops, we have not achieved any of the objectives we had when we entered the war.
If anyone has won, it is Iran. Since the majority of Iraqis are Shia, and since Iraq is divided on sectarian lines, Iran will exert more influence over that nation than anyone else. Considering the current impasse between Iran and the US, the consequences of Iran’s increased role in Iraq could well be dire.
Now What?
First we need to pray, hope, or whatever it is that you do, that the country does not fall apart before our final exit at the end of 2011. Second, we need to learn from our mistakes in Iraq. Even though we are the world’s only super power, we cannot achieve our goals through military action, unless we are supported by a broad coalition of partners who share equally in the combat and cost. Even then, military force must be a last resort. Third, we cannot remake the world in our image. Different cultures develop at different rates, and we cannot change that. Fourth and most important, Afghanistan presents far more military problems than Iraq ever did. The sooner we cut our losses there, the better.
18 Responses to “Editorial: Why? Is it over? Who won? Now what?”
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
It is OUR country that is going to fall apart. Iraq, in plain and simple fact, already has.
Can’t argue with that, JR.
TC
While I’m very happy that at least some of our troops are getting out of there I still have mixed emotions.
Many will come home and be redeployed to Afghanistan. Some will volunteer to go as there’s no jobs here.
I already talked with Jolly Roger about Xe. They will thrive. As a matter of fact their adding people. Their ranks will swell to around 7,000. It all sucks except this, maybe just maybe one of Our troops will come home and Be safe. As most all I want all operations to cease and our people to come home.
No one Won. There was nothing to Win. A War based on a lie. Do you think we learned anything? I don’t.
We’ll get tricked into some other War down the road and do it all over again. I have no faith in Our Government or the people.
Tim, far too many will be redeployed to Afghanistan. Xe will not provide any of those 7,000 contractors. Due to their murderous record, they are banned from Iraq by the Iraqis. I said we need to learn those lessons, but have zero confidence that we will.
TomCat,
That was a remarkable 9/11 experience you shared, and I thank you for it. You have also presented a well-reasoned and accurate portrayal of our involvement in Iraq. Iran has indeed emerged as the “winner”, but so has China for having underwritten our irresponsible indebtedness in waging a war without having it properly financed. As for our learning a lesson from this, I am pessimistic. Iraq proved that we did not learn from Vietnam, and with far-right elements and our military/industrial complex greedier and more powerful than it’s ever been, we may find ourselves in one needless war after another the rest of our lives. I am sincerely hopeful I am wrong about that, but I am not optimistic…war is far too profitable for too many, and a great political tool as well.
Thanks Jack. Your point about China is excellent, and I share your pessimism.
Pardon me for a moment while I thump my chest a few times. WE WON!!! America is still Number One and don’t none of you swarthy tinpot third worlders ever forget it! YeeeHaw!!!
OK, so the cakewalk took seven and a half years instead of two weeks, but still…
Tom, have you been buggering th tea again? 😉
Tom, that was one magnificent post (again). Did you ever hear from the WTC worker’s wife and find out if he got out in time? (I realize he probably didn’t, but still…)
I blogged about the combat troop withdrawal this morning, too, but had to leave the house before I could finish my list all the stuff that’s happened as a result. I didn’t think to add that Iran’s the winner. Feel free to add more to the list if you want.
It’s very doubtful imo that our country learned a damn thing. Just look at the momentum the teabaggers have gained lately. If the economy doesn’t improve pronto (which it won’t until after the mid-term elections) we’re going to lose what little Congressional power we had. And I emphasize the word “little.” (Why yes, I AM doom and gloom, in case you were wondering.)
Thanks, Candace. I never did. I know he didn’t survive, because I contacted the same company again months later. Their entire IT department had been replaced. The man had been theur VP IT.
Your doom and gloom is justified. We have a history of ignoring history.
Those people must be scared to death and they have no Government! right now there are still 56,000 troops there. Soon 50,000 trainers. They will be 50,000 combat troops if needed and they will be along with many others when this success I call hell on earth, spreads throughout the middle east as Bush knew it would but ignored… They do not have Baghdad ranked as the worst city in the world to live in because we did a great job. Our troops did but Bush freed up Iran to raise hell and they are. He should be, never mind.
Well said, my good friend.
The violence is not over; and if America still has 50,000 troops in country, then it is not over yet. Given the goals of the terrorists, we have not won and are losing, but we have not lost yet. Invading Iraq was a worse idea than fighting in Vietnam.
Tom, I’d say the two were equally bad. Both were based on lied. In both we failed to achieve the objectives we had going in.
What a good piece, Tom. I just hope we don’t have a repeat performance.
Thanks Leslie. I share it, but it’s a weak hope.
Excellent piece Tom. I don’t think any of us will ever forget what we were doing on 9/11. You’re right, no one won. And we destroyed a country on the other side of the earth for nothing. It pains the heart to think of what we did to those people and to our own troops for nothing gained and a whole lot of things lost. Sickening, really.
Thanks, Lisa. The only just end for this would be for Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, and several more to be charged, prosecuted, convicted, and sentenced to life without possibility of parole.